<$BlogRSDUrl$>

Tuesday, July 20, 2004

Do the Actions of the US, UK and Their Allied Participants in Iraq Confirm the Tactics of Saddam Hussein? 

Response to: Mike Whitney: Allawi, Our Puppet with a Pistol



Every day another new article in the newspapers tells of US bombings in various locations in Iraq. Innocent people are killed. Abu Ghraib Prison and the abuses that occurred there under US control, the arrest of Iraqis without due process and military actions by ordinary soldiers of the occupying forces seem to mirror the acts of the prior regime. And now a new “Intelligence” service is being established to seek out potential terrorists in the country.
What comes next...a “Republican Guard”, with a different name (of course) to protect the regime currently in power? This is a regime that was “put in place” by occupation forces.
After just one year, the number of dead innocents, though not reported in actual statistics, could challenge the terrible and cruel actions of the previous Iraqi President, Saddam Hussein!
“History” and “Culture” are the real culprits in this folly. “History” as a result of the creation of today’s Iraq by the British in 1925. When different cultures were combined to create a new State, the formula was written for an ungovernable land. Kurds, Sunnites and Shiites merged into a single entity while living in separate and distinct areas were challenged to be ruled by a single power in the Capitol, Bagdad. The different “Cultures” of these three distinct groups and the history of their relationships dictated what had to come to avoid anarchy.
Americans today do not understand cultural differences. Maybe that is because the United States has watched various cultures become homogeneous when they immigrate to America. But culture runs deeper in the rest of the world where people have lived together for thousands of years.
Semites have a unique culture which we see throughout the Middle East today. Be it Israel/Palestine, Iran, or Iraq, Semites are clannish, paternalistic, bound by history and stubborn. Conflict with an outside group provokes a war to the death to preserve “honor”, independence and supremacy. But left in peace, conflict will always develop within the community in a struggle for power and wealth (or wealth and power...I have never been able to learn which was the chicken and which was the egg).
As a minority in 20th century Iraq, the Sunnite dominate the middle of the country, the area lacking wealth from oil. To the north the Kurds, a culture more distant from the Sunnite Arabs then from the majority Shiite Arabs in the south, are also rich in oil. Backed by the US and other western powers, Saddam Hussein maintained his power during the Iranian war using traditional cultural approaches against his enemies. Revolt by Shiites and their allies, the Kurds, after the Gulf War resulted in retaliation required to put down the insurgencies which could have led to his overthrow, but also to anarchy in the country..
Like with the military victory in Afghanistan, the US finds itself a winner without the “spoils of victory”. Having placed a “friend” in position as President of Afghanistan, the US is unable to implement an election of the citizens which will produce the desired results. It is likely the same will happen in Iraq.
If and when there are free and open elections in Iraq, the majority is most likely to win...the Shiites. That could produce a religious government similar to that of Iran, something the US could not accept. The Kurds, who have historically joined with Shiites to fight Sunnite government control, are to small a group to rule. Besides, the Kurds real interest is in an independent Kurdistan, a situation totally unacceptable to the Turks (a key ally of the US from a military strategic viewpoint), a candidate for European Common Market membership, and the Syrians, a key player in the Middle East crisis in the Israeli/Palestinian conflict.

One Approach to Iraqi Democracy
No compromise via direct negotiation will ever be reached either on a cultural nor political level in today’s current borders that constitute the country of Iraq. The US occupation of the country is unable to subdue insurgency in the region of the Sunnite, even with a Sunnite interim government which they put in power. Rebels within the Sunnite community reject the occupation from the outside and the leadership chosen by the conquerors. The Semitic culture of these people will never bow, long term, to US rule nor American capitalistic imperialism. It is viewed as the same as the Germans installation of the Vichey Government during W.W.II. The new US Ambassador, John Negroponte, who replaced Paul Bremmer, the US Administrator after the victory, will continue his role as “watchdog” for American and British oil and oil exploration companies and counselor to the current leadership, always protecting Washington’s interests, but he will not be able to overcome the cultural hurdles which will be ever present.
Scholars must seek a solution to the governing of Iraq without a change of borders, which would evoke widespread negative response from neighbors and non-neighbors alike. A solution may be to allow for ethnic government by region.
A proposal could include the establishment of an Iraqi Confederation, similar to that which exists in Switzerland. Each ethnic group could constitute a “State” (similar to a “Canton” in Switzerland). The State would elect its own leadership and establish a government and a constitution for that State. Each State would also elect representatives to the Federal Government of Iraq. Similar to the situation of Switzerland, the Federal Government would have little power in State affairs. (The President of Switzerland is little heard of outside the country and is elected for one year on a rotating basis from the seven member Swiss Federal Council). The Federal (central) Government of Iraq would have responsibility for monetary policy (currency and central banking), international relations (UN representation, Embassies, Passports, etc.) but each state would set local law. Federal Law would exist only where mutual consent could be reached and by referendum in every State.
There are three Iraqis, and each must be allowed to determine its future. Homogeneous cultural communities do not and will not accept nor react positively to the dictatorship of heterogeneous Western societies.






Sunday, July 18, 2004

EDUCATION: GOING THE "FULL CIRCLE" 


                     
To much is said, and to little done, to develop a real strategy for the future of education globally. The "leader" in the decline of education, the United States, has given the rest of the industrialized world a formula which shifts importance away from teaching and toward finances as both a solution and an excuse for lower performance. Europe and the Far East now lament the decline in scholastics and plead for sufficient funds to correct the situation.

How did we get there and what really needs to be done to put the formation of our most precious commodity, our children, back on the path to a future of ever enhanced prospect and progress?

We have come the full circle in the US. In the late 1950s, social circumstances and poor decisions by educators initiated a move away from excellence in schooling. Today, the students who were taught under the new doctrine are the teachers of our children. To return to "higher standards" requires a full generation, if the process were to begin immediately.

Who should initiate the process and how should it function is open to discussion as well as independent action. Does Government have an obligation? The current Administration used the topic of education as a major campaign platform: Mr. Bush pushed "testing" as the panacea for lifting standards. But education quickly became lost in the events of 9/11 and the subsequent War on Terrorism, Afghanistan and Iraq. What is really important to the citizens of any country, the future as exemplified by it’s youth, was pushed aside for schizophrenic aspirations of global power and influence. Or, does the institution of education have a responsibility to initiate, on its own, practices which will begin a new circle resulting in a era of enlightenment.

History is important since analysis of decline provides potential insight to correcting a fault. A symbol of the beginning of the fall is well expressed with the concept of "The New Math". Seldom mentioned today, perhaps because of its total failure, education took a first step to accommodate students who did not have the ability to comprehend a complex subject by looking for an "easy-fix". Thus was born the concept of "school should be fun". Prior to that time, school was considered "work" for children. Home-work, school-work, and "Do your work!" were the creed of both teachers and parents. Education was a preparation for the adult world, a world where people "work". Be it housework for a mother, the workplace for the breadwinner, or "work-after-school" to bring extra spending money for youngsters, the word work, signified "growing up". School was never considered "fun", even though the social intercourse was enjoyable. "School" was synonymous with "work".

Though the purpose of this document is education and not social reform, the 1956 Supreme Court decision on integration played a major role in changing education in the US. Torn by social injustice for two centuries, minority education became the symbol of equality. History documents Mississippi, marches, and campus violence. Conscience opened the doors to educational decisions which directed the emphasis away from higher standards to accommodation. The real purpose of integration, to provide equal opportunity in education to minority students who were deprived superior teachers and facilities, worked in reverse. Bussed students and forced integration did not always raise the level but instead lowered the standards, since it would be "unjust" to fail those who could not "keep up" with ever increasing complexity in an accelerating world of technology. Teachers were cajoled and enticed to relax curricula to allow all students to prove themselves "competent". Failure became unacceptable...not for the student, but for the teacher. Threatened by lawsuits, school districts chose what seemed the only way out...lower standards, ease curricula, and accept work that was formerly unacceptable.

Higher education either joined the parade or led it. Students could no longer be rejected by universities because of academic shortcomings. More important, institutions of higher learning found that accepting all students could be very "profitable". Enrollment shot up. Tuition increased since more professors were required and new facilities for teaching and housing students were needed. Government’s role was to provide funds to students who wanted, and eventually needed, the University degree to find work in the last half of the 20th century. Education became "big business".

"Big business" is good for the economy! A booming economy is good for the nation! A new "Industry" was born! The business of "learning" provides more jobs, new construction, computers, bigger university hospitals, student loans, profits for lending institutions, and 30 year debt for students studying a profession. America forgot about "education". Euphoria was a sheepskin, student-loan payments, integration, all-star (big business) football and basketball with equality for all. The sports provided more then equality for minorities and "big bucks" for institutions of higher learning.

The rest of the industrialized world looked on with envy. The United States, the land of the desktop computer, Microsoft, the space program, leader in telecommunications, the world of Harvard, Yale and Stamford had the formula for superior education. Follow the leader. America sets the standard. Education is fun!

There is more history. Community leaders in the first half of the 20th century were usually the educated; doctors, clergy and teachers. Respect came with education. And wisdom was associated with those who had the intelligence and fortune to sacrifice years for study in a competitive academic world. Wisdom came from a combination of intellect, education and experience. Those individuals existed not only in the "white" communities of the US but also the "black". Forgotten are the black doctors who treated their patients, understood their needs and illnesses and counseled their family members; the religious leaders who "fathered" the mental stresses within a closed cultured community; and most important, the teachers who worked with parents to prepare children for adulthood. Difficult as it was in a segregated society, education was respected and admired.

Schools taught more then reading, writing and arithmetic. They taught culture, patriotism, history, civics, religion (indirectly), health, science, music, art, sport, the trades (woodwork, sheetmetal, auto mechanics), cooking, sewing and typing for the girls, but first and foremost discipline. All schools taught these subjects, and all children learned these subjects, regardless of race, color or creed. Religious (private) schools were the same and supplemented the public institutions where they were secondary (after school activities).

Discipline was of primary importance...part of "growing up". Teachers were supported in this effort by parents, often too occupied with work providing the financial needs of family. Wise, educated, respected teachers were beyond reproach and "child abuse" was not even a consideration. Boys, in particular, needed discipline to prepare them for the age of 18, when mandatory conscription would require them to accept the discipline of military training...a discipline where "child abuse" did not even exist .

Teachers during the first half of the 20th century were primarily women. It seemed "normal" and "natural" that women, being child bearers, teach children. Thus, women’s rights and respect for women as part of community leadership always existed in the teaching profession. There were other reasons women were teachers. Since they often had families themselves, they could teach and spend after school hours with their own children. Frequent and liberal holiday schedules and long summer vacations made teaching a "practical" professions for mothers. (It still is!) During the World Wars, men teachers were rare, since men were most likely in the military.

Teacher’s pay was commensurate with the number of hours spent on-the-job, considering the vacation and holiday time. As with most work, supplemental hours involving home work is not counted for non-hourly employees. This continues to be true today, although it is never discussed in those terms.

Statistics indicate that in 2003, the average teacher’s salary in the US was $43,000.00. Hours spent in school calculating 13 weeks of holiday and vacation time, with an average school day of 6 hours, excluding lunch and breaks, comes to 1170 hours per year. Thus, the average hourly wage of a teacher in the U. S. is $36.75/hr. Not bad. A famous author and movie director with a NY Times Best Seller Book ridicules the fact that the starting pay for a teacher is $31,900.00. That puts the hourly wage for a starting position at $27.26/hr. The average salary earner in the US has an annual income of $35,300.00 per year, with two weeks vacation and another week of Holidays. His work week is 40 hours. Thus, the average worker, straight time salaried, works 1960 hours per year with an average per hour rate of $18.00. Fringes have not been included in the calculation, but most teachers are union members and have benefits that are at least average to salaried employees in industry, not to mention the job security ("tenure").

Averages tend to be misleading, and NY Times Best Selling authors begin to make enough money that they become separated from reality. Ask any college graduate if he/she would accept a starting job at $31,900.00 per year and I am sure you will get a positive answer in most cases. Ask any graduating medical doctor if he makes $27.26/hr. as a first year intern and he will laugh. A graduating lawyer who has a job offer dreams of 1170 hours a year at the starting hourly rate of a teacher. Although a starting attorney’s annual pay may be more, total hours make for a very tired young person.

It is fair to conclude that pay alone is not the reason for a lack of good teachers. Money will not solve that problem since, as in most cases, salary earned is never enough when compared to Wall Street analysts and corporate CEOs. (We should not forget NBA players and their counterparts in the other sports leagues). Nor should we omit another group of very highly paid executives--in the field of education--the Presidents of major universities. Salaries for these individuals challenge those of their counterparts in the private sector, with the President of the University of Pennsylvania earning in the high 6 figure range.

Money has become an excuse for declining reading scores, lower scientific student enrollment and tragic school crimes. Columbine is a modern facility in a middle class community. Computers in the classroom and amenities such as pastoral settings alone do not guarantee the discipline required for learning. Children of parents from the Far East in general outperform Caucasian students in the US because of the cultural emphasis placed on education and discipline. More money for schools will not change personal values where learning is concerned..

In fact, the business of education, like business in general today, has an insatiable need to accumulate money. Communities would be shocked if a real audit were performed involving local Boards of Education. Wealthy communities have invested tax dollars collected for public education in "Funds" to enhance treasuries. School Boards expend money on travel and entertainment with reckless abandon. State and Federal money is solicited with the pretext of improving education, while in reality the student seldom benefits. And, higher education has become so wealthy from alumni donations, government grants and tuition that it rivals most US Fortune 500 corporations. Like hospitals, not-for-profit status (formal or informal) allows the purchase of needed or not needed technology, outrageous salaries and consulting fees for fund-raising purposes.

Where to begin...

Teachers are the key.

Find the brightest and the best students and train them to be teachers.

The method for doing this has been around for centuries. The US Government does it with the military: West Point, the US Naval Academy and the Air Force Academy. The French created the system of Les Grandes Ecoles: Science Po (politics), l’ENA (government administration), HEC (Business), Saint-Cyr (Military)

Prestigious, elite, superior reputation, respect: these institutions have the most rigorous selection process. In France, two years of preparatory study can qualify a student to compete for a place in one of these Universities. Testing is anonymous...by number -- no affirmative action, no sports recognition, extra curricular activities not included and no excuses that one "tests poorly but is a genius". Take the test and the best scores are accepted.

That acceptance does not guarantee successful completion. Like the US Military Academies, a drop-out rate does exist. Tuition to these schools of high education is free. In fact, Military Academy students receive compensation for their studies. Every businessman knows that if an individual graduated from an Academy, he is disciplined, polished, is a leader and has a fine education in mathematics and science. There is no faking it. There is also an obligation that comes with attendance to these elite schools. Several years of service is required after completion. Beyond that period stipulated, one is free to stay or move on. Graduation insures a position of potential and an open door to the top.

As a famous American humorist puts it: "Santa Claus may come into your life"!

What qualifies one to be a potentially good teacher?

History says education, wisdom (experience) and integrity gained the respect that made the teacher a pillar of the community. Education should be well rounded, not limited to a single subject even if a specialty is existent. Thus, every teacher should have knowledge in the following:
Literature
Mathematics
Science ( Natural and Physical)
Art and Music
Philosophy
Psychology
Language (2/3 spoken languages at a minimum)
Economics
Geography
Government & Politics
History
The ability to communicate effectively both in writing and verbally.

The responsibility to establish these elite schools of higher learning lies not with the Government, but with public and private Universities such as Harvard, University of Chicago and The University of Pennsylvania. Federal government funds could be made available should Congress sanction a formal Proposal of Learning Program detailing the qualification process, curriculum, and criteria for completion and continuation of service.

Graduates would be obligated to teach teachers for the period following completion. They would be free to sell their services on an open market. When their obligation is fulfilled, if the institution they attended had gained a reputation for educating only the brightest and best...their services would be desirable in any private sector corporation. (Santa!)

Under the "trickle-down" theory (Reagonomics not excluded), within 10 years, a notable change would impact the education system. After 20 years, one would come "Full Circle".



This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?