<$BlogRSDUrl$>

Tuesday, July 20, 2004

Do the Actions of the US, UK and Their Allied Participants in Iraq Confirm the Tactics of Saddam Hussein? 

Response to: Mike Whitney: Allawi, Our Puppet with a Pistol



Every day another new article in the newspapers tells of US bombings in various locations in Iraq. Innocent people are killed. Abu Ghraib Prison and the abuses that occurred there under US control, the arrest of Iraqis without due process and military actions by ordinary soldiers of the occupying forces seem to mirror the acts of the prior regime. And now a new “Intelligence” service is being established to seek out potential terrorists in the country.
What comes next...a “Republican Guard”, with a different name (of course) to protect the regime currently in power? This is a regime that was “put in place” by occupation forces.
After just one year, the number of dead innocents, though not reported in actual statistics, could challenge the terrible and cruel actions of the previous Iraqi President, Saddam Hussein!
“History” and “Culture” are the real culprits in this folly. “History” as a result of the creation of today’s Iraq by the British in 1925. When different cultures were combined to create a new State, the formula was written for an ungovernable land. Kurds, Sunnites and Shiites merged into a single entity while living in separate and distinct areas were challenged to be ruled by a single power in the Capitol, Bagdad. The different “Cultures” of these three distinct groups and the history of their relationships dictated what had to come to avoid anarchy.
Americans today do not understand cultural differences. Maybe that is because the United States has watched various cultures become homogeneous when they immigrate to America. But culture runs deeper in the rest of the world where people have lived together for thousands of years.
Semites have a unique culture which we see throughout the Middle East today. Be it Israel/Palestine, Iran, or Iraq, Semites are clannish, paternalistic, bound by history and stubborn. Conflict with an outside group provokes a war to the death to preserve “honor”, independence and supremacy. But left in peace, conflict will always develop within the community in a struggle for power and wealth (or wealth and power...I have never been able to learn which was the chicken and which was the egg).
As a minority in 20th century Iraq, the Sunnite dominate the middle of the country, the area lacking wealth from oil. To the north the Kurds, a culture more distant from the Sunnite Arabs then from the majority Shiite Arabs in the south, are also rich in oil. Backed by the US and other western powers, Saddam Hussein maintained his power during the Iranian war using traditional cultural approaches against his enemies. Revolt by Shiites and their allies, the Kurds, after the Gulf War resulted in retaliation required to put down the insurgencies which could have led to his overthrow, but also to anarchy in the country..
Like with the military victory in Afghanistan, the US finds itself a winner without the “spoils of victory”. Having placed a “friend” in position as President of Afghanistan, the US is unable to implement an election of the citizens which will produce the desired results. It is likely the same will happen in Iraq.
If and when there are free and open elections in Iraq, the majority is most likely to win...the Shiites. That could produce a religious government similar to that of Iran, something the US could not accept. The Kurds, who have historically joined with Shiites to fight Sunnite government control, are to small a group to rule. Besides, the Kurds real interest is in an independent Kurdistan, a situation totally unacceptable to the Turks (a key ally of the US from a military strategic viewpoint), a candidate for European Common Market membership, and the Syrians, a key player in the Middle East crisis in the Israeli/Palestinian conflict.

One Approach to Iraqi Democracy
No compromise via direct negotiation will ever be reached either on a cultural nor political level in today’s current borders that constitute the country of Iraq. The US occupation of the country is unable to subdue insurgency in the region of the Sunnite, even with a Sunnite interim government which they put in power. Rebels within the Sunnite community reject the occupation from the outside and the leadership chosen by the conquerors. The Semitic culture of these people will never bow, long term, to US rule nor American capitalistic imperialism. It is viewed as the same as the Germans installation of the Vichey Government during W.W.II. The new US Ambassador, John Negroponte, who replaced Paul Bremmer, the US Administrator after the victory, will continue his role as “watchdog” for American and British oil and oil exploration companies and counselor to the current leadership, always protecting Washington’s interests, but he will not be able to overcome the cultural hurdles which will be ever present.
Scholars must seek a solution to the governing of Iraq without a change of borders, which would evoke widespread negative response from neighbors and non-neighbors alike. A solution may be to allow for ethnic government by region.
A proposal could include the establishment of an Iraqi Confederation, similar to that which exists in Switzerland. Each ethnic group could constitute a “State” (similar to a “Canton” in Switzerland). The State would elect its own leadership and establish a government and a constitution for that State. Each State would also elect representatives to the Federal Government of Iraq. Similar to the situation of Switzerland, the Federal Government would have little power in State affairs. (The President of Switzerland is little heard of outside the country and is elected for one year on a rotating basis from the seven member Swiss Federal Council). The Federal (central) Government of Iraq would have responsibility for monetary policy (currency and central banking), international relations (UN representation, Embassies, Passports, etc.) but each state would set local law. Federal Law would exist only where mutual consent could be reached and by referendum in every State.
There are three Iraqis, and each must be allowed to determine its future. Homogeneous cultural communities do not and will not accept nor react positively to the dictatorship of heterogeneous Western societies.






Comments:
As the elections grow near, look for more bloodshed. As in Afganistan after the election of a "President", mentalities do not change...acceptance of a real, or semi-real majority will never be accepted and create a peace...real, or semi-real. The middle east is not the U.S. George W. was elected by a majority and the American people accept his. Not so in every culture.

Prepare for another Palestine!
 
Post a Comment

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?